There’s some question about whether local and provincial politicians appreciate and understand how important the housing sector is to the overall health of the Manitoba economy. For example, Winnipeg city council is looking at a significant new tax on new homes to help pay for infrastructure. In addition, the province of Manitoba already levies the highest land transfer tax in the country on all home purchases — a two-per-cent tax rate for any amount over $200,000.
On a recent post, Peter Norman, chief economist of Altus Group, explained the importance of the housing sector to the Canadian economy.
He wrote the following post:
It’s no secret that the housing sector in Canada has been strong and leading the economic recovery since the last recession. Both new housing starts and sales of existing homes through MLS® systems have been buoyant in recent years, although both sectors eased slightly in early 2013.
But just how important has the housing sector been to the revitalization of the Canadian economy? Tremendously! In this post, I explore recent research that points to the important role that resale homes play in the Canadian economy.
It’s easy to understand that new home building, and associated activities, like the development of streets, school, parks and community centres that come with new development, creates economic activity. You can see the jobs created by the construction workers on site, the truck drivers, architects, etc. Moreover, the wood, bricks, steel, glass and other materials manufactured in this country and transported to building sites also have an obvious economic impact.
But a housing resale is a transaction between two parties of a home that was built, sometimes years before. In a good transaction, both parties will benefit, but does this also have spin-off benefits to the rest of us in the economy?
Yes, according to our recent research at Altus Group for the Canadian Real Estate Association, which tracks the many ties between resale housing transactions through MLS® systems and the broader economy.
All told, some $22.5 billion per year of ancillary spending has been generated as a result of purchases and sales of homes through MLS® systems over the 2010-12 period. Moreover, an estimated 176,420 jobs per year were also supported by this activity.
It turns out there are lots of things that home buyers spend money on — spending that is incremental to normal annual spending by households.
Over the first few years following a purchase, home buyers spend on a wide array of goods and professional services, such as furniture, appliances, general household purchases such as bedding, towels, lighting fixtures, tools, blinds, etc., legal fees, appraisals, etc. Also, buyers have moving costs and pay considerable taxes to governments, including land transfer taxes in many jurisdictions.
Over and above all of these obvious spending items is renovation. Most homeowners in Canada spend something on renovation and repair every year, but recent buyers spend a lot more on renovations than the rest of us, up to $9,075 extra over the first few years that they own a home.
All this spending, of course, is good for the economy, and given that recent home sales through MLS® systems have averaged about 452,500 units per year, it adds up to a tremendous boost to Canada’s underlying rate of growth.
Importantly, even if housing sales ease, the economic impacts from recent sales will continue to provide a boost to the economy, given the lags (say, the time between move-in, and the decision to undertake renovations), so there will continue to be positive impacts on the economy from recent activity well into next year.